So, Judge Sonia Sotomayor is a racist because she suggested that she would hopefully reach more fair and just decisions, due to her lifelong experience as a wise latina in America, better than a white man? Many white, conservative males are in fact proclaiming that Sotomayor is in fact a racist for making the remark, and that her intimations make her unfit to be a justice on the Supreme Court. I find this position—their position—somewhat ironic and hypocritical, if not hypercritical on some level.
Of course Sotomayor backed off of her remark, suggesting that it was only meant to inspire the young hispanics in her audience at that time, and that it was a “rhetorical flourish that fell flat.” When you are a racial minority in America who is attempting to get elected or appointed to any type of office or position of authority in government, you have to be politically correct. Well, as a private citizen, I don’t have to worry about my political correctness, and as a person and writer who does not like to beat around the bush, I can tell it like I see it. Some of the same people who are questioning Sotomayor’s ability to be a fair justice have made public remarks that I deem are much more offensive than Sotomayor’s pandering to her latino audience. The main person opposing her nomination is Senator Jeff Sessions. Sessions had the audacity to tell his colleagues one time that he thought the Ku Klux Klan was OK, until he found out that some of them smoked pot. Another leader that many conservative white males look to is Rush Limbaugh. Limbaugh has made such remarks as calling President Barack Obama a halfrican American , and saying that James Earl Ray, the killer of Martin Luther King, deserves a posthomous Medal of Honor. And now people like Sessions and Limbaugh would have you believe that they make fair and just decisions in the performance of their public duty. Don’t get me wrong. People do grow spiritually over time, but casting stones is still casting stones. Senator Sessions, Rush Limbaugh, and others are hypocrites, plain and simple.
Moreover, white men have been atop the leadership in America for hundreds of years. From an economic, social and political standpoint it’s pretty great to be a white male in America. Conditions for hispanics, blacks, American Indians, and even white women, have been a little less favorable. If one scrutinizes the social and economic conditions of minority populations in America, then it is not a stretch to conclude that white male leaders have not been fair and just in their decisions regarding social and economic matters, particularly in regards to racial minorities in America. Now many would say that it’s a person’s own fault if they do not succeed in America, and some would suggest that perhaps blacks and hispanics are just not as intelligent as whites. Yes, it is true that people have to bear the ultimate responsibility for their decisions in life—decisions that have a profound impact upon whether or not someone is successful, but it is very disingenuous and intellectually dishonest to discount the effects of historic and systematic racism and oppression against racial minorities in America. It is highly irrational, if not insane, to deny and/or neglect the adverse results of racism within minority populations in America. People like President Obama, Michelle Obama and Sonia Sotomayor should leave no doubt in anyone’s mind that blacks and hispanics (as well as all racial minorities in America) have just as much innate intelligence as white males. In fact, in some ways, these people are smarter because they have scaled obstacles and barriers that most people have not been able to overcome. It is exactly these obstacles and barriers—along with the life experiences and knowledge attained by being able to confront, challenge and circumvent these unfair impediments that may indeed make Sotomayor better able to reach better decisions than the “good ol’ boys”, because it has afforded her (and others) the ability to see the big picture. People may not want to hear it, but a good number of white men—particularly those who have little direct and/or intimate contact with non-whites—just see things from a myopic, white male perspective. At many times these same people have been in positions of privilege and power for so long that they are just ignorant and/or apathetic to the needs of not only poor blacks and latinos in America, but poor whites as well. Over time, these white males either purposefully or mindlessly adopted a belief that they truly are inherently superior to other races because this is what they know, see, and have experienced all of their lives. After living in this reality they begin to internalize the belief that it is their God given right to be in positions of leadership and legislate to their advantage, and rule as they see fit. These types may attempt to veil their true feelings and the exploitative manner in which they do business, but their position becomes quite evident by scrutinizing the legislation and laws that they do or don’t support. It is their positions that have led to the continued oppression, economic and social malaise of certain racial groups and/or disadvantaged communities within America. Their lack of fairness in the performance of their public duty, along with their basic inability to lead in reference to closing racial disparities within education and other private and public institutions after hundreds of years in America, is the capstone of the institutional racism that still thwarts America’s social and economic infrastructure in the 21st century. If white men can’t get it right after hundreds of years, isn’t it quite natural for someone to think that perhaps a person of color, or maybe even a white woman, could possibly come to better decisions in all areas of government, including the Supreme Court?
White men in America have basically had carte blanche over the decision making at the top levels of federal government for decades. Yes, there have been some blacks, hispanics and women that have slipped through the cracks of the political glass ceiling, but let us not fool ourselves into believing that just because Barack Obama, Sonia Sotomayor, or Hillary Clinton have been able to attain a certain amount of status and authority that the racial and gender floodgates to congressional power have been opened. This truth becomes especailly poignant when you study the historical make-up of the U.S. Congress, particularly the Senate. And, don’t get me wrong: this is not an indictment on all white men in America—far from it. There are plenty of decent, empathetic, fair, just, and wise white men in this country. Just like all black men are not ignorant, violent thugs, all white men are not white supremacist, racist rednecks. There are many who are able to understand that for America to sustain itself as the greatest nation on earth, then everyone should have equal access to social and economic opportunities regardless of race. There are plenty of men like Senator Edward Kennedy, President Bill Clinton, and Bill Gates who don’t make choices or decisions—as a routine matter of course—that cater to the best interests of white men to the detriment of others. But, then you have many white men who cannot and/or refuse to come down from their ivory towers. These are the men who will never have the benefit of the wisdom and experience of a wise latina like Judge Sonia Sotomayor.